Prologue:

Hello and welcome to the return portion of my trip to NY.

This time I will compare my experience with UA's Polaris business class on the competitive SFO - New York market. So far I was impressed with AA. Will UA compare favorably? We'll see.

My ride from Penn Station was smooth and the AirTrain deposited me by the "C" gates at EWR.

photo 640x640 3

I proceeded to the Premier desk to check in. I tried to get my boarding passes online but the UA app did not give me the option to send them to an alternate email address so I printed the boarding pass at the airport. The agent at the entrance was quick and asked if I was flying Polaris. I said yes and when I tried to show my reservation on the phone she waived me saying that she didn't need to see it.

photo 640x640 3

TSA line was not too bad.

photo 640x640 3

Inside terminal C.

photo 640x640 3

UA is the dominant carrier at EWR.

photo 640x640 3

This was the only UA Club open at this massive airport. It's an old facility that is definitely showing its age and is in need of a major renovation.

photo 640x640 3

Entrance.

photo 640x640 3

Reception desk.

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

The lounge is arranged in a circular layout looking out into a food court in the middle.

photo 640x640 3

There a different sections with seating area and cubicles.

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

There are markings on the cubicle walls.

photo 640x640 3

Uneven chair.

photo 640x640 3

Bar.

photo 640x640 3

You had to ask for hot beverages at the bar.

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

The buffet was like a "help yourself" vending machine.

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

WC's. There were about 3 sets of these inside the lounge.

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

I wanted to check out the famous "pop out" lounge and there was a big sign by the Polaris lounge advising people to go to the one by gate C93. When I arrived I saw this sign.

photo 640x640 3

Boarding at the gate.

photo 640x640 3

There was a slight delay because one of the pax had an issue with the agent scanning the boarding passes. There was an announcement about bringing only 2 pieces of carryons and apparently the pax had 3..

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

At the entrance a FA was giving each pax a disinfectant wipe.

photo 640x640 3

Polaris cabin.

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

My seat 9A.

photo 640x640 3

Amenity kit pillow and blanket at the seat.

photo 640x640 3

Screen

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

Lamp.

photo 640x640 3

Reading light.

photo 640x640 3

Notice the narrow exit to the aisle.

photo 640x640 3

Footrest.

photo 640x640 3

Seat control.

photo 640x640 3

Compartment for headphone and bottle of water.

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

Mirror.

photo 640x640 3

Tray table.

photo 640x640 3

Tablet mode.

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

No magazine.

photo 640x640 3

Saks Fifth Av. pillow and blanket. The pillow cover was very smooth.

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

WC before take off. The seat was dirty. I don't know if that was a cleaning oversight or someone used it after being cleaned.

photo 640x640 3

Toiletries.

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

Safety video.

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

FA's asked each pax about the dinner choice - chicken pad thai OR vegetarian ravioli. There was no printed menu like AA. I said to the FA "I take all of the above". She replied "you must be hungry". :P

photo 640x640 3

Amenity kit.

photo 640x640 3

Very basic and there is no hand lotion.

photo 640x640 3

I ordered my half cranberry and orange juice mix. I was given 2 cans of each to mix it on my own. Let's play bartender!

photo 640x640 3

Everything was individually wrapped. The dish had 3 layers of aluminum paper covering it. I noticed that there was no ice cream on my tray and when I reminded the FA she apologized and brought it back right away.

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

Too much sauce on the pad thai but it was delicious.

photo 640x640 3

Dessert.

photo 640x640 3

Nothing like a nap after a meal.

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

Drink and snack before arrival. There were two snack baskets on the credenza at the front of the cabin.

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

Landing @ SFO.

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

Intercontinental Times Square.

photo 640x640 3

I had a decent stay at this contemporary and stylish property.

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

Comfortable room but there was no bath robe and pen/paper at the desk. I don't know if the lack of these are Covid19 related.

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

View from my room.

photo 640x640 3

Restaurant was closed. They only serve continental breakfast during the weekends.

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

photo 640x640 3

Shake Shack around the corner of the hotel.

photo 640x640 3

Hotel exterior.

photo 640x640 3

========== Newark Liberty Intl Arpt (EWR) - ==========



Security/Immigration efficiency: 9/10
Access and parking: 9/10
Services and activities: 9/10
General cleanliness: 9/10

========== United Club Gate C74 ==========



Staff Service: 9/10
Entertainment: 4/10
Business Center: /10
Food: 4/10
Lounge Design: 4/10
Spa and Bathroom: 4/10
Wifi: 10/10

========== United Airlines - Airline ==========



Cabine comfort: 9/10
Crew: 9/10
Entertainment: 9/10
On-time performance: 10/10
Appetizer: 8/10
Starter: 0/10
Main Meal: 9/10
Main Meal-2: 0/10
Cheese: 0/10
Desserts: 8/10
Alcohols: 0/10
Mid-flight snack: 0/10
Breakfast or light meal before arrival: 0/10

========== San Francisco Intl Arpt (SFO) - ==========



Security/Immigration efficiency: 10/10
Access and parking: 9/10
Services and activities: 9/10
General cleanliness: 10/10

Summary:

The UA Club experience was disappointing and not what is expected from an airline at its major hub. The lounge is old and showing its age. Catering is limited to packaged snacks. At least UA can make an effort to serve hot soup like AA. There were a few pax not wearing masks inside the club.

The Polaris cabin looks nice with direct aisle access for all seats. However the narrow entrance to the seat is a bit annoying. The amenity kit feels cheap and not as generous as the AA one. The lack of a printed menu, beverage service before the actual meal and limited choices for main dish are some negatives. .

However the crew was friendly and the main dish was delicious.

17 Comments

  • Capoune


    Hello Adan!

    Not as good as AA on the previous flight but not so bad at all.
    The show experience during Covid is disappointing but at least it's open!
    Onboard some imperfections but the cabin is beautiful and for a domestic flight the service remains correct.
    Very beautiful pics as always!!

    Thank you for sharing with us this very nice report.
    Take car panda!

    Reply
    jetsetpanda
    Hi Seb,

    I'm thankful that we can fly during these difficult times and appreciate the people working in the aviation industry, especially the crew on both AA and UA doing their job with a smile and being friendly.

    The cabin of the 787 is very reassuring and beautiful as you said.

    See you later. ;)
  • GG_007


    Thanks for sharing this TR

    This lounge really needs improvements but at least it was almost empty

    " I said to the FA "I take all of the above". She replied "you must be hungry". :P"
    A hungry panda ! ^^
    She has to be careful with him

    Nuts on the tray : a very good point

    "Too much sauce on the pad thai but it was delicious."
    It looks yummy

    Even if the choice was limited I prefer the UA tray above the AA's
    BTW I would have asked for the second choice too ;)

    All in all a good flight but in your opinion the AA experience was better

    See you soon

    Reply
    jetsetpanda
    Salut GG,

    Imagine if the lounge was full. That would have been catastrophic.

    "Nuts on the tray : a very good point"
    - I prefer to have the nuts served with a beverage before the meal. ;)

    "It looks yummy"
    - I think a laksa soup would work perfectly. :)

    "BTW I would have asked for the second choice too ;)"
    - The cabin was full. I doubt they would have extras. :P

    AA felt more premium.


  • Thomas


    A great report my friend. Oh the pad thai we were talking about. Indeed !!!!!!!!!!! The cabin in nice.
    The lounge is below average but not surprising :(
    A good hotel.
    It feels so good being in the air :)
    Thanks again dear.

    Reply
    jetsetpanda
    Hi Thomas,

    I wonder if it's better to have less choices as long as they are done well and turn out delicious. Personally I think both choices sounded good on this flight.

    It's not often that UA surprises you.

    A nice room in a central location. You can't beat that.

    Being in the air is essential for avgeeks. ;)
  • Emile


    Thanks Adan for this very nice review. I can't deny the lounge sucks while the product onboard is good.
    have a good day.

    Reply
    jetsetpanda
    Hi Emile

    It's a contrasting experience for sure. Hopefully they will have more renovated lounges soon.
  • Casper


    Gracias Amigo.
    A superb report. Not the best meal but with so many months without flying I would take this in a heartbeat.
    The hotel is looking good.
    Casper

    Reply
    jetsetpanda
    Hola Casper,

    Glad you liked it. The presentation and appetizer could have been better but at least the main dish was good. I also appreciate having ice cream as dessert.

    The hotel was a good choic

  • AAFlyer


    Once again you scored a great report Panda. It was a pleasure reading it. It was a good showdown on both airlines.

    Reply
    jetsetpanda
    Hi AAFlyer,

    Round 1 over. Wait for round 2 starting tomorrow. ;)
  • Vendredi13


    Ouaf ! JetSetPanda !

    At first, I felt your report surprisingly close and different from your previous flight...
    So I took time and i just reread your outbound flight in order to understand this feeling..
    Yes Both Airports and lounges are painted in white tones. Yes The cabin of the 2 planes seem similar. And yes one report looks new, the other one is "vintage". Actually, you built this return flight review exactly like the outbound flight. Comparison is eased. Thanks JetSet' ! it's very informative.
    And there is no picture.
    I love the public notice displayed on the door of the Polaris Lounge, at the extremity of the concourse. I would have written something else.

    Thanks, Panda, for this excellent YTR.

    Reply
    jetsetpanda
    Sorry for my late reply mon oauf,

    Anything to make my reports easy to comprehend. ;)

    The notice on the Polaris lounge is a little misleading. They shouldn't have pax going all over the place for nothing. I guess the exercise was good. :P
  • samlecorsaire


    Again a very nice TR Panda thanks a lot.
    I love the 787 and I loved the cabin with the polaris seat
    bye

    Reply
    jetsetpanda
    Hi Sam,

    My apologies for responding so late.

    The 787 is a nice plane with a comfortable J cabin for sure.

    See you.

Login to post a comment.